October 24, 2024

Why Pay Goodwill for a Business That Is Trading at a Loss?

Matt Stevenson

Managing Director


When it comes to buying a business, one of the common questions prospective buyers ask is: why should they pay goodwill for a business that is currently trading at a loss? The concept of goodwill can be challenging to grasp, especially when financials are negative, but it plays a significant role in the valuation of many businesses. Let’s explore why this might make sense in some situations.

Understanding Goodwill

Goodwill represents the intangible assets of a business—those qualities that cannot be measured precisely but have real value. These might include brand reputation, loyal customer base, supplier relationships, skilled workforce, proprietary systems, or even the strategic location of the business. Essentially, goodwill is the premium a buyer is willing to pay over the value of the tangible assets because they see potential in the business that extends beyond what is currently reflected on the balance sheet.

Potential for Turnaround

In many cases, businesses that are trading at a loss may still have strong foundations that can be leveraged for a turnaround. Buyers might see opportunities to improve operational efficiency, cut unnecessary costs, or invest in marketing to drive sales. Often, a business trading at a loss may still hold strategic value—like access to an established customer base or market—that would take significant time and resources to build from scratch. Paying goodwill is essentially betting on the ability to unlock this potential and turn the business profitable.

Buying Market Position

Even if a business is losing money, it might have built up valuable market share that a buyer can capitalize on. Entering a competitive market can be incredibly challenging without an established presence, and goodwill can represent the value of taking over an existing foothold. Instead of starting from zero, the buyer gets a head start—complete with existing customers, suppliers, and market recognition.

Synergies and Strategic Fit

For some buyers, especially those in the same industry, purchasing a business that is trading at a loss may offer synergies that create significant value. The acquired business might have complementary products or services, key suppliers, or even intellectual property that enhances the buyer’s existing operations. In these cases, the value of goodwill lies in the strategic fit and the additional revenue streams or cost savings that can result from combining the two entities.

Acquisition as a Growth Strategy

For larger players in the market, acquiring a smaller competitor—even one trading at a loss—can be a way to expand market reach or eliminate competition. The goodwill paid in such acquisitions is often justified by the anticipated benefits of growth or market consolidation. For example, the acquirer might reduce duplicated costs, combine sales channels, or increase their negotiating power with suppliers.

Final Thoughts

Paying goodwill for a business that is trading at a loss can make sense in certain situations. It requires a buyer to have a vision for what they can achieve with the business, and a solid plan to extract value from its intangible assets. Goodwill isn’t just about the present state of the business; it reflects the future potential that can be unlocked.

For buyers, it’s essential to evaluate all aspects of the business—including its intangible assets, market position, and potential synergies—to determine if the goodwill is justified. A business may be trading at a loss now, but with the right strategy and execution, it could become a valuable asset in the future.

More insights

How to buy Bizstats

Unlock business insights with our step-by-step guide to purchasing a Bizstats report.

Market Based Valuation 101

Understand your business's value with Market-Based Valuation: a simple, fast method using real sales data.

Bizstats Terminology

Navigate Bizstats reports with clarity by understanding the report data fields.

Value Modifiers in Business Valuation

Learn about value modifiers in business valuation and how factors like customer concentration, brand, and operational efficiency affect the final price.

Gathering Information for a Business Valuation

Learn how to gather comprehensive information for a business valuation.

Key Factors That Impact Earnings Multiples in Business Valuation

For small to medium-sized businesses (SMEs), Seller’s Discretionary Earnings (SDE) is the most relevant measure…

New Zealand's only database of business sales statistics